What
is Legalism? Colossians 2:20-3:7, Romans 6:1-22
One
of the themes that has often been distorted, misunderstood, in some cases
abused, in the teachings of the Scripture on the Christian life has to do with
this concept of being crucified with Christ. Other passages in Scripture,
passages such as what Jesus says, that if we want to follow Him we must deny
ourselves, take up our cross daily and follow Him. Other passages that Paul
uses talk about putting to death the deeds of the flesh, putting to deeds the
deeds of the sin nature, reckoning ourselves dead to sin. So often when we read
and hear these things, either due to an over familiarity of the passages we
don’t really stop and think about what they mean, or too often they have been
presented within the context of a legalistic approach to the Christian life
that leaves us recognizing that it is just another superficial understanding of
the Christian life, a wrong understanding of the Christian life, or it is just
another kind of gimmick that really doesn’t seem to work in our life and we are
still fighting the same battles that we always fought.
It
is important to understand these passages because they all connect. Another
problem that we have that comes across in this kind of study is that too often
under a rather narrow, restricted view of pastoral ministry, or the pulpit
ministry more precisely, of what it means to teach or preach expositionally is that pastors tend to focus on just what a
particular set of verses says without recognizing that that is like one piece
of a jigsaw puzzle or one piece of a mosaic and we really need to understand
all of the other pieces and how they all relate together in order to get the
picture. The Scriptures aren’t written like a systematic theology where Paul is
writing to one group or another and says this is all you need to know about the
Christian life in these next eight verses or nine principles or ten principles.
We have in the Scriptures, as it were pictures or snapshots. In Romans 6,
Colossians 3, Galatians 5, 1 John, Ephesians 3, 4, 5 different snapshots that
all have to be put together to really understand everything that we have been
given in Christ and how we are to think. Because one thing that comes across
again and again and again in these passages in the fact that the writers of
Scripture all come back to saying words like “know this, understand this,” or
“reckon yourselves dead to sin,” as Paul says in Romans 6:11, which really
means to think in these terms consistently. So how do we put this together?
This is what we are trying to do as we look at the real heart of Colossians,
which are the verses between 2:5 to the beginning of chapter four.
One
thing we should address before we really get into the topic itself is the
question of what is legalism. What exactly do we mean when we use this term
“legalism”? Sometimes people think that any time somebody comes along and says,
“You are a Christian and you shouldn’t do that,” that they are being
legalistic. Well the apostle Paul said a lot of things in the imperative mood
that said you should do this and you shouldn’t do that. It is not legalism; it
has to do with setting the standards in the lifestyle of a believer. There are
some difficult passages in 1 John that say that if you are born again you don’t
sin. How do we handle a verse like that: that if you are born from above you
don’t sin? All of these mandates should be understood in light of an analogy:
that you have a father, the head of the household who has set down a behaviour
code for his family, and this is how people in this family conduct their lives.
And if you break those standards then you might hear the father say this isn’t
how our family lives, you don’t do that if you are a member of this family. He
is not saying that you are not a member of the family; he is saying that you
are not acting of living like a member of the family; you are not following the
code of conduct that should be the standard for a member of the family. That is
how Paul and Peter and John and others in the New Testament really address the
Christian life; they have laid down a code of conduct that we should aspire to.
We are going to fail. That is why we have 1 John 1:9, not so we can get out of
jail free, as it were, ahead of time and say, Okay, even if I sin it’s no big
deal. It is a big deal because there is always divine discipline and
consequences whether we want to admit that or not. But it is a way of recovery
because God knows that we still have this nasty thing called a sin nature and
we are still going to sin.
Until
the day we die we are all going to struggle with sin because there is, as Paul
explains in Galatians 5:17-19, this war that we have going on inside of us
because although we have been given a new nature we still have that old nature,
the sin nature. The sin nature wars against the spirit and the spirit wars
against the sin nature, and that is the way it is going to be until the day we
die.
Legalism
isn’t saying that there are standards or absolutes for the Christian life; it
is a wrong approach to those standards. By defining it legalism is at root the
idea that a person’s behaviour influences, motivates or causes God’s gracious
actions in justification (salvation) or spiritual growth. It is the idea that
what you do is somehow the basis for God’s blessing—either giving you
salvation or in the spiritual life various blessings that go along with the
spiritual life in terms of spiritual growth, that it is my behaviour or your
behaviour that is the real cause of God’s blessing. That is what legalism is.
Example:
There is the person who is saying I need to pray every day. That is in a system
of thought that says if I don’t pray every day God is not going to bless me,
this is what is going to cause spiritual growth. I need to read my Bible every
day, and if I don’t read my Bible every day God is not going to bless me and He
is not going to do anything in my life. That person is wrong because he is
approaching it from a legalistic concept. He thinks that those things he does,
no matter what they are is what really motivates God. On the other hand, there
is the believer who understands that it is all based upon God the Holy Spirit
working the Word of God in his life. He still needs to make these decisions but
he does it by means of the Spirit, and it is all based on grace and God has
already blessed him with every blessing in the heavenlies;
therefore he can’t do something to get more blessing, he already has them all.
He just has to realise them in his own experience.
The
grace-oriented believer is not going to get bent out of shape when he fails
because he understands that that is not the basis for blessing. The basis for
blessing is the work of Christ, the righteousness of Christ he possess not his
own righteousness. We call that being grace oriented. It is not legalism. And
this person realises that he needs to pray every day because that is our
lifeline to God and the Scripture says we are to pray without ceasing. But he
doesn’t do it for the same reason the legalistic person does it. This person
realises he needs to read his Bible every day, not because by reading his Bible
every day is going to get God to bless him—it is not some spiritual good
luck charm or rabbit’s foot—but that by reading his Bible in fellowship
under the ministry of God the Holy Spirit he is going to be reminded of all the
wonderful things that God has done for him, provided for him, and he is going
to be encouraged and strengthened as God the Holy Spirit uses the Word in his
life to remind him of what he should do. They are both saying we need to do the
same thing but one is doing it for a legalistic for a legalistic reason, the
other is doing it our of grace orientation.
So
legalism is not the same as identifying oughts and ought-nots in the Christian
life; it is not the same as saying Christians shouldn’t do X, Y or Z or that
they should do A, B, and C. That is not legalism. What legalism is, is making
non-Scriptural mandates necessary—like saying, I don’t smoke, I don’t
chew, and I don’t go with girls that do—and I’m more spiritual! The Bible
doesn’t say anything about those things. What often happens in churches is
there is this wrong approach to the oughts and the ought-nots of the Christian
life. They often make non-Scriptural mandates absolutes.
Legalism
in the spiritual life may emphasise the same absolutes—like pray, read
your Bible, go to Bible class all the time—but it does it in the power of
the flesh. The spiritual life as we understand it does many of the same things
by the power of the Spirit. What legalism does is reduce the spiritual life to
nothing more than a morality system, a sort of pull-yourself-up-by-your-own
bootstraps approach to the Christian life.
But
when we get into the heart and soul of what we are teaching this morning we
should understand that this is not legalism. This is how we are to think as we
are in fellowship, walking by the Spirit, being filled by means of the Spirit,
walking in the truth, and abiding in Christ. When we sin we get out of
fellowship and we are not doing any of those things anymore but we can fool
everybody, including ourselves, by a pseudo spirituality that is simple
morality generated by the flesh. This was the problem with the Galatians.
Galatians 3:3 NASB “Are
you so foolish? Having begun by the Spirit, are you now being
perfected by the flesh [sin nature]?” They had bought into the same legalistic
idea from the Judaisers who came through there who
said it was okay that they had trusted Christ as their saviour, but now that
they were saved they needed to be circumcised and to follow the Mosaic Law, and
if they didn’t then God was just not going to bless them. There was no
understanding of the role of God the Holy Spirit.
The problem that Paul was
dealing with in Colossians was that what they had decided to do was look at
various systems of legalism that came out of a mysticism background, Greek
philosophy background, mystical Jusdaism background,
and they had incorporated that as the standard for the Christian life. In
essence what Paul was saying is they had cut themselves off from Christ, the
head of the body. They were trying to live as if they were alive and drawing
their sustenance from the head but had been spiritually decapitated because, in
the language of Galatians, they were trying to reach maturity by the flesh. By
cutting themselves off from Christ they were not under the authority of Christ,
they were not receiving nourishment from Christ, they were not going to receive
their spiritual growth from Christ, they were not going to receive strength
from Christ, and this was going to put in jeopardy all future rewards,
privileges and blessings in the kingdom.
What Paul is saying is that
there is a solution. When you recover you have to understand and put into
practice in your thinking certain things. You have to understand your position
in Christ. That is fundamental in Paul’s thinking. Paul is saying if you don’t
understand what you have in Christ then you are just never going to get very
far in the Christian life. It is not complicated but you have to understand
that we have already been given these things in Christ, these possessions are
ours; we don’t have to reform our life so that God will give them to us. They
are ours and we just have to learn how to implement them in terms of our thinking.
We have to learn to live in light of their reality and develop a mindset based
on that reality and then, as he puts it, we need to put to death the sin in our
life. And that is the question: what does this mean, to put to death the sin in
our life?
Now we want to emphasise
what is meant by putting to death and having already put to death the sin
nature—this putting to death terminology, that we have been crucified
with Christ. In Colossians 2:11, 12 Paul reminds them that we have been buried with
Him in baptism. Since God isn’t in the business of burying live people we
recognise that burial follows death and so what is implied by being buried with
Him in baptism is a preceding death which is our identification with Christ in
His death, burial and resurrection which is part of what is referred to in
Scripture as the baptism by means of the Holy Spirit. In Colossians 2:20
Paul says, NASB “If you have died [and you did] with Christ …” Then
in Colossians 3:3 he says, “For you have died …” There is no “if” clause here,
he is stating the reality of that—“… and your life is hidden with Christ
in God.” Then he says in Colossians 3:5 NASB “Therefore consider the
members of your earthly body as dead to immorality, impurity, passion, evil
desire, and greed, which amounts to idolatry.” If I died, why do I have to put
to death the members? That is that tension we see in Scripture that some people
don’t see. It is the difference between our positional reality,
i.e. of the fact that we have died to the sin nature. But the reality is that
it is still there, it is just that the tyranny of the sin nature has been
broken and so experientially we have to put to death the deeds of the flesh in
an ongoing manner as part of our spiritual life. This is related to the idea of
putting off the sin nature and it is going to be explained further in
Colossians 3:8ff.
Identification truth is understanding what we have in Christ. Because in the Acts
of baptism by means of the Holy Spirit we are identified with Christ in His
death, burial and resurrection so that we are one in Christ, we have put Him
on, we are intimately and integrally united with Christ. We can’t be separated
at all. This our position in Christ and what Paul is referring to in Colossians
2:20 NASB “If you have died with Christ
[and you did]…” Then in Colossians 3:3 NASB “For [because] you have
died and your life is hidden with Christ in God.”
Why
did we die with Christ? Because we were crucified with Him.
We are identified with His crucifixion, so intimately that we are said to have
died to everything that went before we believed on Him. Paul comes to a
conclusion: Romans 6:8 NASB
“Now if we have died with Christ, we believe that we shall also live with Him.”
So death has an implication of new life. That is what Paul is going to develop,
especially when he gets to Romans chapter eight. Notice the similarity in the
language with Colossians 2:20 where he says, “If you died with Christ.” Same
phrase. So if we connect these two passages, because they are both talking about
the implications of having already died with Christ when we are identified with
Him through the baptism by means of the Holy Spirit, Paul says in Colossians
2:20 NASB “If you have died with Christ to the elementary principles
of the world, why, as if you were living in the world, do you submit yourself
to decrees [regulations]?” Paul had regulations, but they are not the same
regulations. They regulations Paul had are done within the framework of walking
by the Spirit. In Romans chapter six Paul says, [11] “Even so consider [think]”
–logizomai which means to
reason from a conclusion. “…yourselves to be dead to
sin.” What Paul is basically saying here is to logically (on the basis of what
he has just taught) reason to the conclusion in your mind that you are dead to
sin and that a separation has occurred in relation to your obedience to the
tyranny of the sin nature. And not only to yourselves
to be dead to sin, that is the negative side. But consider yourselves to be
“alive to God in Christ Jesus.” Notice it is part of being in Christ. Live on
the basis that you are now alive; you were dead before.
So what are we to do?
Romans 6:12 NASB “Therefore do not let sin
reign in your mortal body so that you obey its lusts.” That is the physical
body. The physical body, as Paul develops on into Romans chapter eight, just
doesn’t connect with spiritual truth. Because the sin nature is in the body it
has to be controlled by your mind implementing the realities of your spiritual
position in Christ. So Paul says don’t let sin reign in your mortal bodies.
That’s not legalism. If we want to grow and experience the full life that God
has for us in the Christian life then this is what we have to do. We can’t just
continue to sin and then confess it and say we will be in fellowship, and we
are not going to worry about making those hard decisions to not do what really
appeals to me and what my sin nature drives me to do. We can’t let the sin
nature reign, we have to let Christ and the Word of God reign in our life and
thinking. We have to obey the Holy Spirit and the Word of God rather than the
sin nature. Those are the options.
Romans 6:13 NASB
“and do not go on presenting the members of your body to sin {as} instruments
of unrighteousness; but present yourselves to God as those alive from the dead,
and your members {as} instruments of righteousness to God.” That is a hard
thing to do.
The key word that we find
throughout Romans 6 has been this idea of death and crucifixion. Paul says it a
little differently in Galatians 5:24 NASB “Now those who belong to
Christ Jesus have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires.” This is a
place where some people have just sort of miss-stepped a little bit. If we look
at Galatians 5, starting at verse 16, we have a command to walk by means of the
Spirit. It is in the present tense. And if we look at every verb all the way
from verse 16 to the end of the chapter—which is all about the spiritual
life and what it means top walk by the Spirit and the fruit of the Spirit—every
verb is in the present tense, because it is always talking about our present
walk with Christ until we get to verse 24 which is a past tense verb. Some try
to argue that this isn’t a present tense use of the aorist. We have to disagree
with that because it stands out in this whole flow of verbs. The emphasis here
is on the crucifixion of the flesh that occurred at the baptism by the Holy
Spirit. So if we are Christ’s then that has already occurred and this is
related to what Paul had said earlier, “I have been crucified with Christ.” But
in Galatians 2:20 it is a passive voice; in 5:24 it
is an active voice. Some have tried to make a distinction there and have said
that in Romans 6 and Galatians 2 it is passive, that our flesh is
crucified—God performs the action; we have received the benefit of
it—but Galatians 5:24 is an active voice verse so it ought to be
understood differently because we are the ones performing the action.
But there are many other
places where Paul uses the same thing. We are the cause of this action because
it is the instant that we put our faith and trust in Christ that is what
dominoes that chain of events that occurs that begins with the baptism by the
Holy Spirit. My volition is engaged when I believed Jesus Christ died on the
cross for my sins. It is that choice that dominoes because God is going to
instantly baptize me by means of the Holy Spirit. So in that sense I cause that
crucifixion with Christ but it is really God who does both those things.
Paul goes on to say in
Galatians 5:25 that this is done by walking in the Spirit. If we live in the
Spirit—that’s that new life that we have because the old man has been
crucified with Christ—let us now walk by means of the Spirit. This is the
temporal reality. We are to walk by means of the Spirit, Galatians 5:16. This
is the word peripateo which focuses on a lifestyle. But when we get down to
Galatians 5:25 it is a different word, a word that means walking step by step,
following a path. It is often used of troops marching in ranks. So it is
emphasising the walking not so much as a lifestyle but as a step by step,
following the guidance of the Holy Spirit through God’s Word.
Back in Romans 6:13 Paul
had said, “Don’t present your members as instruments of unrighteousness to sin,
but present yourselves to God as being alive from the dead and your members
[physical body] as instruments to God.” When we skip to the end of the story in
Romans eight to pick up the final part of what Paul says on the spiritual life,
he says, Romans 8:11 NASB “But if the Spirit of Him who raised Jesus
from the dead dwells in you [and He does], He who raised Christ Jesus from the
dead will also give life to your mortal bodies through His Spirit who dwells in
you.” That is not talking about resurrection life or future life in terms of
resurrection or rapture, it is talking about experiencing the full life, the
abundant life, that we are to have in Christ here and now in our mortal bodies.
How do we do that? Through the Spirit. Not by going
out and making ourselves more ethical and moral but by learning to walk by
means of the Spirit; and in the power of the Holy Spirit, then, we make these
other decisions to implement the mandates of Scripture in our life.
Romans 8:12 NASB
“So then, brethren, we are under obligation, not to the flesh, to live
according to the flesh—[13] for if you are living according to the flesh,
you must die [carnal death]; but if by the Spirit you are putting to death the
deeds of the body, you will live.” This is not talking about being saved and
going to heaven when we die, it is talking about having that real, rich, full
spiritual life right here and now. Paul uses here the Greek verb thanatao to put to death the deeds of the
body, but in our passage in Colossians 3:5 he says, NASB “Therefore
consider the members of your earthly body as dead to immorality, impurity,
passion, evil desire, and greed, which amounts to idolatry.” There he uses the
word nekrao. In the ancient medical
world they used the word nekrao to
refer to flesh or body parts that no longer functioned. Today we use the term
“necrotic.” Flesh that has died has become necrotic is no longer useable. This
is the idea that Paul has here: putting to death the deeds of the body; put to
death the members that are on the earth. Putting to death the deeds of the
body: that physical expression of the sin nature. In other words, we are
putting to death or killing off something, to assassinate something, to send
out a search and destroy mission from our soul by means of the Holy Spirit to
destroy the practices of sin in the body. That just stands for our physical
existence, our physical life. In other words, we are to begin rendering the
effects of the sin in our life and in our obedience to the sin nature as a
necrotic tissue; it no longer functions.
But we don’t just go out
and do it on our own. That is where legalism comes in. Legalism says we have to
do this by don’t do this and do this, and we’ll be okay. Anybody can do that,
and it is miserable. Only the Christian who understands what Paul says can do
it in fellowship by the Holy Spirit. Then and only then can it be done, because
the Holy Spirit ultimately is the one who makes that happen. We are empowered
by Him. That doesn’t mean He takes over our volition. We have to say, I am not
going to do that; instead, I’m going to walk by the Spirit, I am going to do
what the Word of God says to do. I still have to engage our volition and that
involves self-discipline.
Some people say that is
legalism. But wait a minute. Paul was the one who said that he wanted to run
the race (his life) as to win, like a contest. And in order to do that he said
he beat his body into submission. That means that he is engaged in a struggle against
his sin nature. And as much as he wants to say yes to his sin nature he is
going to exercise that discipline and say no, and is going to walk by the
Spirit, and the Spirit is going to deal with that and over time that is going
to be dealt with.
Matthew 16:24 NASB
“Then Jesus said to His disciples, ‘If anyone wishes to come after Me, he must
deny himself, and take up his cross and follow Me.’” When Jesus said “If anyone
wishes to come after me,” He is not talking about going to heaven, He is
talking about being a true student of Jesus and implement the Christian life.
He says first of all you have to deny yourself. What He means by that is saying
no to the sin nature. Then He says, “and take up his cross and follow me.” What
does that mean?
A lot of the things that
Jesus said are not understood by a Greek or Gentile mindset because we don’t
understand the Hebrew idioms that underlie them, or we don’t understand enough
about the original context and how these words became idioms in the original
historical context. In the Roman empire
if you did not submit yourself to Rome and were a
criminal by violating the laws of Rome, and you
violated those laws in the most extreme manner, then you were punished by
crucifixion. In order to assert the fact that you were now being forced to
submit to the authority of Rome, and to warn others
who may be tempted to rebel against the authority of Rome,
the criminal was required to carry his cross to the place of execution. It was
the sign that he had now been forced to submit to the authority of Rome,
and you had better not rebel or this is what is going to happen to you. So
taking up your cross became an idiom for submitting to authority. All Jesus us
saying here is that if you want to follow Him, just as Jesus submitted to the
authority of the Father you have to submit to the authority of Christ. We have
to do what the Bible says to do, basically. That is what taking up the cross
means. You have to follow God’s plan for your life, which means to do what the
Word of God says to do and not do what it says not to do—just like Jesus
followed the plan of God which meant going to the cross and dying for our sins.
And it is there that that power of sin is ultimately broken.
So it is not legalism to
deal with sin in our life. We never compromise the standard. We hold up the
standard high but we also recognise that we are always going to fail and God
knows we are always going to fail, and God is not giving us an unrealistic
goal, He is giving us an impossible goal because we can’t do it. But the Holy
Spirit can and only when we walk by the Spirit are we then empowered to make
the choice to obey the Lord. That is what it means to take up the cross daily.
This gives us the
full-robed foundation for what the Scripture teaches on moving forward in the
spiritual life.